The one question mark for me over Pep has always been that he’s only ever managed teams with a massive advantage over the rest of the league.
At Barca he had Messi and possibly the greatest playmaking team ever assembled. At Bayern… it’s obvious, and so is City… Even at Barca B, they were normally either in 2nd or 3rd tier and that year were in 3rd tier, so were one of the best teams in the league they were in.
At City he inherited one of the best teams in the league and underperformed until he got 200m worth of fullbacks.
He’s never done anything like winning the CL with Porto.
I wouldn’t say there is a stereotype about the players at all, apart from not producing as much talent as they probably could. If you’re good enough you’re good enough, the PL has players from all over the world.
About the fans and analysis though…