Here are the results from the poll posted in May. (https://lemmy.ca/post/64421437)
Google Drive: https://drive.google.com/drive/mobile/folders/12yFvkpWgWpSsx200KUUnyVsW2wbfwowf
YouTube Video: https://youtu.be/V7khLevB3wU
Top 7
- D&D (all editions)
- Pathfinder (all editions)
- Daggerheart
- Shadowdark
- Draw Steel
- Nimble
- Call of Cthulhu (all editions)
Special callout from Bob to Cottagecore Goblin Lesbians Destroy Capitalism RPG.
I understand that in some countries, Call of Cthulhu is more popular than D&D, based mainly on a series of video interviews by Don’t Stop Thinking asking about various DungeonTubers’ local scenes. Pathfinder was also lesser-known outside the US at the time of those interviews, though that might have changed by now since the interviews happened before the OGL debacle of 2023.
I recall Call of Cthulhu is huge in Japan.
Yep! The relative smallness of D&D in Japan is only secondarily about Sword World existing, and primarily about just how popular CoC is there, from what I can tell. CoC seems to just generally be better-known internationally than Pathfinder is, or was at the time at least.
My d&d group tried daggerheart for a few sessions. It felt very incomplete. We have discussed trying draw steel, but I could not get everyone to commit.
What felt incomplete about it to you?
I absolutely love Shadowdark. I just can’t find anyone to play it with. Fantastic game, though.
Shadowdark has very appealing features
- real-time torches
- simple ancestry
- 2 page classes
- limited carrying capacity
- shorten stat block
- high risk high reward casting system
- loot based xp system
- large font
It’s a nice refreshing meal of OSR while still holding a 5E blankey.
I totally agree, and apparently so do a lot of people. :)





