• 1 Post
  • 635 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: March 31st, 2025

help-circle




  • sounds good, no obvious critical materials but also first facilities are just in single MW range and came online like two months ago. needs like four orders of magnitude more. already matches lead acid on durability, still less than li-ion. maybe it’s solvable, but in case it’s not you can just burn it down because there’s nothing worthwhile to recycle and it’s nontoxic

    this happens a lot. lithium anything has this problem obviously, but so do flow batteries (vanadium or zinc bromide - bromine is commercially sourced just from either dead sea or some american underground brines). some lithium batteries also use cobalt. hydrogen generation or fuel cells use a lot of platinum, (some of) new power electronics are made from GaN. etc etc





  • either sub or aircraft carrier reactors might be somewhere around 50 to 220MWe, panamax might need 60MWe tops, regular land based PWRs are more like 300MWe and up. the smaller you go, the higher enrichment you need, but also military propulsion has different priorities, they use 90%+ enrichment in part because they can, and in part because this gives them massive excess reactivity, which means power level can change ridiculously fast. tradeoff is that spent fuel has much more useful uranium, and it’s overall expensive, but you also don’t skimp on your doomsday ride so it’s all fine. commercial powerplants are physically capable of doing slower load following, but it’s more economical most of the time to just use full power in order to best utilize fissile material. what you’re proposing would have all disadvantages of both, because no way in hell this thing will run on standard, low enriched fuel for PWRs, it might need something maybe more than 5%, maybe closer to 10%, perhaps more, which means problems, because it means worse proliferation risks than with normal fuel and it’s already fuel that goes around, and can be taken over in some unfriendly waters; higher enrichment also means it’ll be much more expensive, both because of more SWU needed, but also because it’s a specialty product that requires extra licensing; and it also won’t be as compact and responsive as military reactor, because civilians don’t get to play with HEU like that; and also it will require refueling after some time, maybe longer than regular-sized PWR (refueling every year to three) that probably will require visit to manufacturer to do refueling there, which would be, everything else equal, a bit harder than in regular powerplant because it needs to be done in a drydock

    it has all disadvantages of SMRs but also you can steal them on high seas and it’s probably great for diplomacy if some random ass pirate get hands on that




  • high latitude is sort of served by hydro because there’s lot of river per person in some of areas that are in any significant way populated (norway, russian north)

    medical isotopes are research reactor thing because of frequent loading/unloading - either that or some kind of channel reactors so either CANDU or RBMK. neither are exactly industry standard

    marine power requires small reactors = way more enriched than usual sub 5% = expensive and a lot of diplomatic noise about proliferation



  • renewable generation, i’m with you, but i’m not sold on storage. i’m not even sure if there’s enough lithium for grid batteries to seriously matter, so it might need to use something else. the boring, working option (geographically limited) is of course pumped storage hydro, but other than that, i think that the right way to do things is to use energy when it’s made, not when it’s needed. in particular, water heaters have tiny duty cycle and hot water just sits there, which means you could, in principle, make it so that water heaters soak up all, or at least as much as practical, of excess power, wherever it is available

    some countries do fund nuclear power as a kind of strategic energy independence hedge* no matter costs, most prominently france and russia, and to some degree india and a couple of others

    *also for military use