We moved to America in 2015, in time for my kid to start third grade. Now she’s a year away from graduating high school (!) and I’ve had a front-row seat for the US K-12 system in a district rated as one of the best in the country. There were ups and downs, but high school has been a monster.
–
If you’d like an essay-formatted version of this thread to read or share, here’s a link to it on pluralistic.net, my surveillance-free, ad-free, tracker-free blog:
https://pluralistic.net/2024/01/16/flexibility-in-the-margins/#a-commons
1/
@spbollin@mas.to @pluralistic@mamot.fr In all the AP classes I took (late '80s) there was some review for the exam that involved practices, but it was mostly just going over what sorts of topics tended to be covered, with practice exams mostly covering how the exam worked rather than hyper-specific methods of trying to optimize scores (e.g., for AP English, what a typical literary critique/analysis question would look like and what it would ask). The AP English rubric I mentioned was the actual College Board grading rubric from exams administered a year or two beforehand, rather than an in-class preparation, which is part of the reason it came to mind as such a big difference from Cory’s description of weeks upon weeks of fine-tuning essay style and format as part of AP English nowadays.
@spbollin@mas.to @pluralistic@mamot.fr And while we’re on the subject: I know for a fact that at no point in my high school or college “generic expository writing experience” (through the early '90s) did I ever have to adhere to something like the “five paragraph essay format” that seems to be what people nowadays think of as an “essay”, and which ChatGPT can regurgitate, with superficial content but absolutely perfect form. Of course, a lot of short essays I wrote would have been about 5 paragraphs long and would have followed a pattern of “intro, various supporting topics, conclusions”, but through a dozen or more classes in English, history, and social sciences, where this sort of writing was routine, what mattered was actually being able to support an argument. The specific structural details were a lot less important. I’d like to think that’s still very real at the college level; I’m rather less optimistic at the high school level in much of the US.
@dpnash@c.im @pluralistic@mamot.fr I feel pretty lucky. Both AP classes, not regularly offered, were “rewards” for really good teachers who were given wide latitude to teach what they wanted to teach. I’m realizing now that it was a reward for me, too!
We have a teenager in high school currently. It is completely “teach to State/AP/whatever test”, only proving Corey’s points. And the high-stakes testing consumes at least a week of each semester.