The Israeli rescue service Zaka says its paramedics removed more than 260 bodies from a music festival that came under attack by Hamas militants.

The total figure of bodies found is expected to be higher, as other paramedic teams were also working in the area and Zaka added that the bodies “haven’t all been collected yet”.

Early on Saturday morning, Hamas targeted Nova music festival, a techno rave in the desert near the border with Gaza.

Videos shared on social media and by Israeli news outlets showed dozens of festival-goers running through an open field as gunshots rang out. Many hid in nearby fruit orchards or were gunned down as they fled.

  • be_excellent_to_each_other@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    Kbin refuses to let me expand your comment to see anything after the sentence beginning with “the naive and now utterly…”

    But this isn’t doing much to make me more sympathetic to the Israeli plight, and is more or less what I thought. I assumed I must have been wrong or misinformed, but you seem to have confirmed I really shouldn’t have much sympathy for Israel overall, even if I agree this attack on a music festival seems hard to specifically defend.

    The West Bank is divided into three areas: A - administered by the Palestinian Authority, B - jointly administered by the PA and Israel, and C - administered by Israel. Israel has been increasingly building more and more settlements within Area C, which are widely recognized as illegal and being incredibly counter-productive towards peace. The Israelis who move there are often extremely nationalistic and often commit violence against the Palestinians.

    • BraveSirZaphod@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      Weird, I’m also from Kbin. Also unfortunate, given that the rest contains a lot more context.

      Ultimately though, I think the desire to label one side and fundamentally right and the other wrong is simply far too simplistic to be useful. Anyone interested in peace will criticize both sides as neither has done very much to move towards peace; Israel is just a lot better at protecting its citizens from harm. But fundamentally, peace will be impossible so long as Israel’s safety is threatened, and any acts that threaten that only make peace impossible.

      • Apologies I missed this reply yesterday.

        Weird, I’m also from Kbin. Also unfortunate, given that the rest contains a lot more context.

        It happens from time to time, I’m not sure why. I tried turning off KES previously to see if it was somehow misbehaving, but it doesn’t seem to make a difference.

        I did go read the rest this morning on lemmy directly.

        I see your points, but coming at it from the angle of what do we do today, I still come away feeling like the obvious answer (I say that recognizing this war is thousands of years old and no such thing will happen) is for Israel to stop these settlements.

        Until they do, Palestinians have a pretty valid claim that Israel is the instigator and these actions (or, one would hope, more focused actions) are required to preserve their homes and community.

        Pull back the settlements, take whatever measures are deemed necessary to secure the border, and leave them the fuck alone. The whole angle about no one else claiming that land feels pretextual to me, and feeds my perception that Israel is just ratcheting up the pressure to provoke the Palestinians so they can claim they are justified when the level the place by actions like OP.

        I’m not by any means raging at you, I appreciate the explanation, but it sure feels to me like a situation where it’s easy to paint the Palestinians with a broad brush, but also hard to understand how anyone thinks what Israel is doing here is right.

        • BraveSirZaphod@kbin.social
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          Without a doubt, I think the settlements are abhorrent and incredibly counter-productive to peace. They’re not recognized by literally any other country for that express reason.

          However, that does not justify the actions that took place over the weekend. If the aim was military resistance to Israel and a desire to assert independence, there are plenty of military targets surrounding Gaza that could have been attacked. Instead, they mostly went into civilian settings and simply murdered as many people as possible, while also raping and kidnapping many. I just read a report about babies being decapitated. You’ve probably already heard about the plans to livestream the executions of hostages.

          These actions cannot be defended or justified, ever. They can be explained, and I do think it’s not wrong to say that some of Israel’s actions have contributed towards the environment decaying so much that they became more possible (though it’s beyond tactless to say if that’s your first thought in the face of the events). But it is possible to analyze the context of these events while still condemning them, which is something many many progressives have utterly failed to do. I saw just this morning someone I’d considered a friend talk about how it should be impossible to support Palestinians without supporting Hamas and all actions they deem necessary, and that any attempts to talk about nuance are a deliberate western strategy to distract.

          Given what has happened, which was, again, a deliberate attempt to kill as many Israeli citizens as possible, I do think Israel is justified in taking steps to ensure that this never happens again, and it’s tragic that many innocent people are going to suffer because of that. However, Hamas could at any time give up hostages and de-militarize, and there would be no further bloodshed, whereas if Israel laid down arms, it would be a second Holocaust, as evidenced by this past weekend.

          I think my ultimate position, which I’ve come to realize is not as universal as I thought, is that I believe there is no cause so righteous that it can ever justify the murder, kidnapping, and rape of innocent civilians. You can explain and understand the context that leads to the build-up of anger and resentment that ultimately causes such a violent outburst - and I dearly hope Israel does take valuable lessons moving forward, though I’d be surprised - but those actions can never be accepted, and retaliation to ensure that they do not re-occur is justified.

          • be_excellent_to_each_other@kbin.social
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            edit-2
            1 year ago

            (For whatever reason I had to go read your comment on Lemmy again.)

            Without a doubt, I think the settlements are abhorrent and incredibly counter-productive to peace. They’re not recognized by literally any other country for that express reason.

            However, that does not justify the actions that took place over the weekend.

            I completely agree that there are no good guys here, and targeting an explicitly non-military target like a music festival is not something to be justified.

            They can be explained, and I do think it’s not wrong to say that some of Israel’s actions have contributed

            They can’t just be explained, they can be easily explained, I think.

            As everyone keeps pointing out, Israel is far stronger militarily and likely could ethnic cleanse Gaza if they chose (edit:and seem to be often lauded for their restraint in not being worse than they are to the Palestinians). And that sounds great until you wonder then why don’t they use their strength in a way that doesn’t escalate? They can choose not to ratchet things up, but from what I’m reading they already have. And I think we also agree that the continued existence of the settlements is an unending provocation.

            https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israel-palestine-war-gaza-area-bombed-after-warning-to-move

            https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/israel-bombs-egypt-border-crossing-it-had-touted-as-an-escape-route-for-besieged-palestinians/ar-AA1hYfk2

            That’s not “we’re going in to get whoever did this and we’re not being too polite about it”, that’s pretty wanton targeting of civilians. You don’t create more people who want to fight fair doing those things, especially when your side is NOT the “barely subsisting” side, but rather the side that possesses the technology and skill to be far more surgical if they chose.

            I’ve lived my entire life in the US and I have uncritically accepted our relationship with Israel for most of my life. But their actions are no easier to defend than Hamas’ actions in some cases, IMO.