From the opinion piece:
Our research at MIT helped make the case for ride-sharing. We were wrong. We don’t want to make the same mistake with robotaxis …
What? How did anyone think that Uber could possibly help traffic?
Uber whas supposed to make some guys rich, what are you all smoking?
Well yeah, the solution to traffic is mass transit. Invest in rail and busses if you want to solve traffic, and then build density around stations. That way most of my traffic is between stations, and busses feed the rail system.
It’s not complicated. Uber and other ride share services are designed to replace taxis, not reduce traffic.
I suspect that the “logic” behind the Uber will reduce traffic argument would give me a headache.
There is an argument, and it’s pretty straightforward and reasonable. In congested cities, a large percent of drivers (I’ve seen as high as 1/3 for downtown Manhattan pre-pandemic) are within a few blocks of destination and are actively seeking parking, and Uber doesn’t need to park. Which does imply an actually-correct argument – the amount of parking you need in a city to support cars being the primary transportation mode is ridiculous.
But the entire sales pitch of Uber is that it will be so quick and easy that you’ll use it without a thought. Their entire business model is to generate more trips, not consolidate or reduce trips. There is no incentive in them to reduce how long their users spend on the road absent competition with bikeped/public transit. There’s a reason Uber pools never caught on. Obviously the easier car trips get, the more people will make trips by car. And while the parking geometry is insane, the road geometry of non-parking vehicles being the primary transportation mode is barely any better. Especially when you consider you’ve simply shifted a large number of vehicles-seeking-parking into vehicles-seeking-fare.
Absent any investment in better bikeped and public transportation, it is possible Uber can have a marginal improvement to congestion. But not enough to really make a difference and improve anyones’ lives. And it’s also possible it slightly worsens it by generating trips that otherwise would’ve simply not happened because the traffic sucked too bad.
One person in a 2 ton metal box will never fix traffic, it does not matter who or what is driving.
It’s two people when it comes to Uber though (for now).
But only one of them needs to get somewhere.
